Missed Out on These Hidden Gems? 5 Amazing Board Games You Should Play Right Now

Every hobby has its hidden treasures, the things you only discover once you step off the beaten path. And in the world of board games, some of the best experiences aren’t the ones plastered all over TikTok or selling out in seconds.

Some gems sit quietly on the shelf, waiting for someone curious enough to pick them up. And honestly? Those are often my favourite discoveries.

If you’re using a board game subscription through Love Board Games, this is exactly where the magic happens. Because you can borrow board games without risk, you get to explore unique titles you may never have thought to buy.

Here are five criminally underrated games in our collection that deserve your table right now.

1. Jamaica – A Swashbuckling Race Full of Mischief

Let’s start with a game that absolutely oozes charm. Jamaica is a pirate-themed racing game where you’re sailing around the island, loading treasure, firing cannons, and — of course — sabotaging your mates.

What makes it a hidden gem? It’s light, fast, and laugh-out-loud fun, but still packed with strategy. The dice-based action selection is clever without being overwhelming, and every game feels like a holiday in a box.

If you want a game that’s easy to teach, looks stunning, and gets everyone talking, Jamaica is your next adventure.

2. Kanagawa – Painting Lessons From a Master Artist

Beautiful, peaceful, and quietly competitive, Kanagawa is one of the most elegant games I’ve ever played. You’re students learning the art of painting under the legendary master Hokusai.

Why it deserves more love: It’s a perfect balance of calm decision-making and gentle push-your-luck tension. The artwork is breath-taking, the gameplay is clever, and the experience feels almost meditative, until someone snatches the card you wanted, of course.

If you’ve never tried this one, trust me… you’re missing out.

3. Maglev Metro – Trains, Technology, and Transparent Track Tiles

Now for something futuristic. Maglev Metro mixes route-building with engine-building in the most stylish way imaginable. You’re creating a magnetically levitating train network, using clear track pieces that literally float over each other.

Why it’s a must-play: It takes the familiar “train game” formula and gives it a sleek, modern twist. Your board starts tiny and explodes into something beautiful as your engine improves.

This one is ideal for players who love strategy but want something fresher than the classics. And thanks to our rent board games service, you can try it without dropping £60+ on a gamble.

4. Paranormal Detectives – Solve Mysteries… In the Weirdest Ways Possible

Imagine Cluedo… but the ghost can actually talk to you, and the detectives try to interpret their clues through charades, symbols, drawings, and bizarre physical challenges.

Yes, it’s as hilarious as it sounds.

Why it’s a hidden treasure: Every round feels completely different, the deduction is genuinely clever, and the way clues are communicated creates some of the funniest moments I’ve ever had at a table.

This one shines with families, teens, mixed groups — really anyone who enjoys a bit of absurdity with their mystery-solving.

5. The River – A Relaxing Journey Into Settlement Building

The River is a game I always describe as “Catan’s chill younger cousin.” You’re developing a riverside settlement, placing workers, building tiles, and gathering resources — but without any of the stress or “why did you steal my sheep?”

Why it's a gem: It’s simple enough for families, satisfying enough for gamers, and short enough to fit into any evening. It’s a pure comfort game — warm, wholesome, and endlessly replayable.

And because you can borrow board games from Love Board Games, you can try this underrated beauty without committing shelf space or money.

Why Hidden Gems Shine Brightest With Love Board Games

When you buy games, you tend to stick to what’s popular. It feels safer. But when you use a board game subscription, suddenly your curiosity can take over.

You can explore.

You can experiment.

And you can discover the games that everyone should be talking about.

Hidden gems become easy, affordable, and exciting — because you can play them, love them, and send them back for the next discovery.

If you’re ready to dig deeper and find your next favourite game, check out our full selection and start your adventure today.